What 300 Companies Found About Their Own Performance Process
Almost everybody runs one. Very few think it works. The gap is where the useful detail is.
Talent Strategy Group's global performance management research surveyed 300 companies across 15 industries and 10 countries. The headline numbers are not flattering, and they are more useful than the usual commentary about annual reviews being dead, because they separate the process from the people running it.
Near universal
- 95% of companies have a performance management process
- Of the 5% without one, more than half planned to introduce one within a year
- Nearly 80% require goals to be recorded in a software platform
Rarely effective
- Fewer than 20% rated their process highly effective at feedback, coaching, performance improvement, accurate reviews or development
- Just over 20% said so for goal setting
- 53% of employees satisfied with the process
Constantly rebuilt
- 88% redesigned the process in the previous four years
- 50% redesigned it in the previous two
- Most set goals once a year, and most allow changes but rarely make them
The finding that explains the others
Two numbers in the research do more work than the rest. Twelve per cent of leaders were judged capable of delivering high quality coaching and feedback. Twenty three per cent were judged capable of setting challenging goals.
Put those next to the redesign statistic and the pattern is hard to miss. Companies dissatisfied with their performance process overwhelmingly respond by changing the process: fewer rating levels, a new platform, continuous check-ins instead of annual reviews, a simpler form. Eighty eight per cent of them did this in four years. Meanwhile the capability that the process depends on sat at twelve per cent, and redesigning a form does not move it.
This is the most expensive mistake in the field. A performance process is a set of containers for managerial judgement. If the judgement is weak, a better container produces the same weak judgement in a tidier layout, at the cost of a year of change management and the goodwill of everyone who has to learn the new system.
Where the dissatisfaction comes from
The research locates employee dissatisfaction in two places, and neither is the form. The first is fairness: the perception that the manager is biased, or that the criteria are unclear enough that the rating is effectively discretionary. The second is usefulness: a review that produces no specific feedback and no clear statement of what to do next. An employee can accept a rating they dislike. They struggle with a rating nobody can account for, and they get nothing at all from one that comes with no direction.
Both of those are manager capability problems with process consequences. Clear criteria are written by someone who knows how to write them. Specific feedback is given by someone who collected evidence through the year and has a form of words for the difficult part. Neither is solved by a platform.
Who gets left out
One finding deserves more attention than it usually gets. The employees most often excluded from the performance process are front line, hourly, unionised and works council covered staff, and in some organisations the senior executives, who were reported as not following the same process as everybody else. Exclusion at the bottom and at the top, for opposite reasons, tells you something about what the process is actually for in those companies.
What the report recommends, and what it is worth
The recommendations are sensible and mostly unsurprising: be clear what the process is for before designing it, simplify it, prioritise the quality of goals over the quantity, cascade organisational priorities so people know why their deliverables matter. The one that carries the weight is the second: train leaders in goal setting, feedback and reviews. Given the twelve per cent figure, it is also the only one that addresses the binding constraint.
Source: The Global Performance Management Report, Talent Strategy Group. Figures above are as reported in that research.
Training the capability the research found missing
Goal setting, feedback and the appraisal conversation are what the Certificate in Performance Management covers, and they are precisely the capabilities the report found scarce. Ten modules, about twelve hours, assessed by an online exam with a 70% pass mark.
